This repository has been archived on 2026-09-13. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
BPOS-MVP/apps/api/src/modules/process/internal/usecase/process-service.ts
T
ChaiHaoandClaude Opus 5 78622b8799 审批点后面补上网关 G3,并让引擎**真的走它** —— 顺带给去向旗找到落脚处
两件事,都是「图上画着、实际走不到」这一类。

## ① 审批点后面没有网关(用户提出)

A5 只有一条出边 A5→A6,驳回走向藏在 `reject` 声明里,图上只是一枚牌子。
BPMN 的常规是审批的两个去向都由网关决定 —— 补 G3「审批结果」,
`verdict = "pass"` → A6,`verdict = "reject"` → A4(回边)。

补的时候撞上真问题:`onApprovalVerdict` 只在 pass 时走 `advanceFrom`,
而且 payload 里**不含 verdict** —— 于是 G3 没有判据可读。异或分叉的每条出边都得带条件、
没有无条件兜底边,判据一缺就全不成立,流会无声停在 G3。

能让闸过的最省事办法是在 `e-a5-g3` 上喂一枚常量 `verdict: "pass"`。**没那么做** ——
那样 G3 的条件恒真、驳回边永不可达,网关就是个摆设,又是一处「画着两个去向、
其中一个结构上走不到」的谎。

改的是引擎:裁决进载荷,通过与驳回**都先看图**,只有没画驳回边的包才退回 `reject` 声明
(它 schema 必填,且是通用机制)。`advanceFrom` 因此回报「有没有真的推出去」,
并加 `quiet` 参数 —— 「先试边、不成再退回声明」这一步试空是正常分支,不是死路,
不该报 route-dead-end 假警。

`reject` 保留:schema 必填、CONTRACT.md 的不变量、且审批人界面拿它渲染人读文案。
它与 `e-g3-a4` 必须字字对齐,加了测试守。

## ② 几何重排:两带换行,不回形

原坐标逐点抄自 MVP 的 SVG,是回形走线(row 0 左→右、row 1 右→左、row 2 折回最左)——
这正是上一轮流程链读成 A1→A7→A2 的根源。重排为两带:
受理·选型·寻源(y 60..100)→ 换行车道 y=190 → 定价·审批·议价·成交(y 310..350)→
未成交闭环(y 410..450)。每带内 x 随推进次序单调递增。

实测渲染(画布 639×325):带 0 的 A1 57→G1 159→A2 223→G2 325→A3 389→G2J 491,
带 1 的 A4 38→A5 153→G3 242→A6 293→G4 395,**零框重叠**。
两枚回 A4 的卡点同一条车道、同朝向(向上=回退)。

## ③ 顺带:两枚去向旗终于有地方落

上一轮我在债务簿写「A1 过不了 G1 是诚实状态、不是缺陷」——**判断错了**。
出口的标量字段只从落地事实取,而 `needAlternative` / `needSourcing`
在任何台账对象上都没有列,活动实现了也一样取不到。

新增 `project.intake_verdict`「受理结论」**一单一行**(主键只有询价单号)。
为什么不挂在按料号分行的「统一受理记录」上:`flat` 是把这一单所有落地行 reduce 展开,
六个料号就有六行同名列、最后合并的那行赢 —— 而归并规则是「任一条命中 C 即需选型」,
last-write-wins 会静默给出错的去向。测试正反两面都守:结论表主键只能是 rfq_ref,
且**其它对象上不许出现去向旗**。

A2 也要回写这一行,所以 `rfqRef` 进了 G1→A2 的边映射,并**正式声明进 A2 的入参**——
不声明也能偷渡(闭合校验遇到未声明的目标直接跳过),但那是默许不是正当。
A2 的 contract.version 因此升 0.2.0,包版升 0.5.0。

顺手删了一个陈旧草稿 v2:它是我早前测编辑器留下的旧图(14 节点、无 G3),
而种子刚把 v1 用新图重发布 —— 草稿内容比已发布版更旧,谁发布它 G3 就没了。
删前确认零工作流引用。系统没有「丢弃草稿」的入口,这条记进债务簿。

typecheck ✓ lint ✓ depcruise 374 模块 ✓ api:check ✓ 495 测试 ✓
发布闸实测:15 节点 / 18 边,边映射闭合校验通过。

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KeDBx2PHLavbURXB8LJJ7m
2026-07-28 12:24:40 +08:00

508 lines
22 KiB
TypeScript

/**
* process 用例 —— 流程引擎:确定性流转,**零 LLM、零临场**(编码规范 §5.3;语义出处 OS 03 / 04)。
*
* 起单 · 调度节点 · 审批点卡工位 · 网关分合 · 每次流转记入事件。
*/
import type { ProcessNode, ProcessPackage, StaffId, TerminalState, WorkflowState } from '@contracts';
import type { ProcessService, StartWorkflowInput } from '../../contract.ts';
import { CallInterfaceViolationError, NotPublishableError, PositionVacantError } from '../../contract.ts';
import type {
ActivityDirectory,
ApprovalGateway,
Clock,
FlowEventPublisher,
IdGenerator,
OrgDirectory,
ProcessStore,
ReceiptNotifier,
SchemaValidator,
Sfeel,
TaskGateway,
WorkflowRecord,
} from '../../port.ts';
import { checkClosure } from '../domain/closure.ts';
import { aggregateWorkflowState, isDigested, nextInstanceNumber, resolveOwner } from '../domain/owner-resolution.ts';
import type { NodeInstance } from '../domain/owner-resolution.ts';
import { assemble, dispatchOf, joinReady, rejectRouteOf, selectEdges, startNodeOf } from '../domain/routing.ts';
export type ProcessServiceDeps = {
readonly store: ProcessStore;
readonly activities: ActivityDirectory;
readonly org: OrgDirectory;
readonly tasks: TaskGateway;
readonly approvals: ApprovalGateway;
readonly sfeel: Sfeel;
readonly schemas: SchemaValidator;
readonly events: FlowEventPublisher;
readonly receipts: ReceiptNotifier;
readonly clock: Clock;
readonly ids: IdGenerator;
};
export function createProcessService(deps: ProcessServiceDeps): ProcessService {
async function requirePackage(id: string, version?: number): Promise<ProcessPackage> {
const pkg = await deps.store.getPackage(id, version);
if (pkg === undefined) throw new Error(`流程包不存在:${id}`);
return pkg;
}
/**
* 起单取版:未指定版本时取**最新已发布** —— 草稿不入选。
* 若按「最新版本」取,治理台一存草稿,起单立刻被没发布的定义顶住;
* 草稿是编排中的半成品,运行时永远不该看见它。
*/
async function latestPublished(id: string): Promise<ProcessPackage> {
const all = await deps.store.listPackages();
const hit = all
.filter((pkg) => pkg.id === id && pkg.state === 'published')
.sort((a, b) => b.version - a.version)[0];
if (hit === undefined) throw new Error(`流程包无已发布版本,不得起单:${id}`);
return hit;
}
async function requireWorkflow(id: string): Promise<WorkflowRecord> {
const record = await deps.store.getWorkflow(id);
if (record === undefined) throw new Error(`工作流不存在:${id}`);
return record;
}
function scopeOf(record: WorkflowRecord) {
return { ports: record.ports, vars: record.vars, initiation: record.initiation };
}
/** 起一个节点:活动 → 起单;审批点 → 卡工位;终点 → 收束 */
async function enter(
record: WorkflowRecord,
pkg: ProcessPackage,
node: ProcessNode,
payload: Record<string, unknown>,
): Promise<void> {
const dispatch = dispatchOf(node, payload);
if (dispatch === undefined) {
// 网关本身不是责任单元:直接继续流转
await advanceFrom(record, pkg, node.id, payload);
return;
}
const instances = await deps.store.listInstances(record.id);
const instance = nextInstanceNumber(instances, node.id);
if (dispatch.kind === 'finish') {
await deps.store.insertInstance(record.id, {
nodeId: node.id,
instance,
running: false,
waiting: false,
activated: true,
terminal: 'released',
});
const finished = await deps.store.updateWorkflow(record.id, {
state: 'completed',
finishedAt: deps.clock.now().toISOString(),
ports: { ...record.ports, __output: payload },
});
await deps.events.publish({ workflowId: record.id, kind: 'workflow-completed', detail: payload });
// 凡单必有来源 —— 登记人收消息回执
if (record.source.by !== undefined) {
await deps.receipts.notify({
to: record.source.by as StaffId,
workflowId: record.id,
subject: record.subject,
state: finished.state,
});
}
return;
}
// 负责人 / 审批人:编排声明岗位,起单时确定性解析;结果与依据留痕
const spec = dispatch.kind === 'start-task' ? dispatch.node.owner : dispatch.node.approver;
const candidates = await deps.org.candidates(spec.position);
/*
* 绑定先于策略:工作组说了这个岗位是谁,策略就无从发问(ADR-011)。
* 在岗与否在这里核 —— 绑定是**跨岗位**指派,拿该岗位的候选集核不了它。
*/
const boundTo = record.workGroup?.[spec.position];
const bound = boundTo !== undefined && (await deps.org.isActive(boundTo)) ? boundTo : undefined;
const resolution = resolveOwner(spec, { candidates, ...(bound === undefined ? {} : { bound }) });
if (resolution.kind === 'vacant') throw new PositionVacantError(spec.position);
await deps.events.publish({
workflowId: record.id,
kind: 'owner-resolved',
detail: { nodeId: node.id, position: spec.position, staffId: resolution.staffId, by: resolution.by, rationale: resolution.rationale },
});
if (dispatch.kind === 'start-task') {
const task = await deps.tasks.start({
activityId: dispatch.node.activityId,
ownerId: resolution.staffId as StaffId,
title: dispatch.node.label,
workflowId: record.id,
nodeId: node.id,
data: payload,
...(dispatch.node.message === undefined ? {} : { message: dispatch.node.message }),
});
await deps.store.insertInstance(record.id, {
nodeId: node.id,
instance,
running: true,
waiting: false,
activated: true,
taskId: task.id,
});
await deps.events.publish({ workflowId: record.id, kind: 'task-started', detail: { nodeId: node.id, taskId: task.id } });
return;
}
const approval = await deps.approvals.raise({
workflowId: record.id,
nodeId: node.id,
approverId: resolution.staffId as StaffId,
subject: dispatch.node.label,
basis: Object.entries(payload).map(([k, v]) => ({ k, v: String(v) })),
});
await deps.store.insertInstance(record.id, {
nodeId: node.id,
instance,
running: false,
waiting: true,
activated: true,
approvalId: approval.id,
});
await deps.events.publish({ workflowId: record.id, kind: 'approval-raised', detail: { nodeId: node.id, approvalId: approval.id } });
}
/**
* 从某节点继续流转:选边 → 装配 → 进下一节点(AND 汇合要回齐)。
*
* 返回**有没有真的推出去**。审批点的驳回要用它:图上显式画了驳回出边就走边,
* 没画的包才退回 `reject` 声明 —— 调用方据此判断,不必自己再选一遍边。
*
* `quiet` 为真时不发 `route-dead-end`:那种「先试边、不成再退回声明」的探路
* 一条边都没中是**正常分支**,不是死路,报出来就是假警。
*/
async function advanceFrom(
record: WorkflowRecord,
pkg: ProcessPackage,
fromNodeId: string,
payload: Record<string, unknown>,
quiet = false,
): Promise<boolean> {
const scope = scopeOf(record);
const flat = { ...scope.initiation, ...scope.vars, ...payload };
const edges = selectEdges(pkg, fromNodeId, flat, deps.sfeel.condition);
/*
* 一条边都没选中,而这个节点确实有出边 —— 流到此为止,再没有谁会来推它。
* 这是**死路**,不是终点。异或网关最容易碰上:发布闸要求它的每条出边都带条件,
* 所以没有无条件兜底边可用,判据一缺就全不成立(实测:A1 的出口少了两枚去向旗,
* G1 一条分支都选不中,流无声停在 A1)。
*
* 状态聚合已经会把它报成 `abnormal`(没到终点就不算完成),但那只说「有问题」、
* 不说「哪儿有问题」。这里留一条可诊断的痕:哪个节点、出边各自的条件、判据里到底有哪些键。
* 只记键名不记值 —— 诊断够用,载荷不进事件明文。
*/
if (edges.length === 0) {
const outgoing = pkg.edges.filter((e) => e.from === fromNodeId);
if (outgoing.length > 0 && !quiet) {
await deps.events.publish({
workflowId: record.id,
kind: 'route-dead-end',
detail: {
nodeId: fromNodeId,
edges: outgoing.map((e) => ({ id: e.id, to: e.to, condition: e.condition ?? '(无条件)' })),
availableKeys: Object.keys(flat).sort(),
},
});
}
}
for (const edge of edges) {
const target = pkg.nodes.find((n) => n.id === edge.to);
if (target === undefined) continue;
if (target.kind === 'gateway' && target.mode === 'join') {
const instances = await deps.store.listInstances(record.id);
const converged = new Set(instances.filter((i) => i.terminal === 'released').map((i) => i.nodeId));
const tolerated = new Set(instances.filter((i) => i.failureDigested === true).map((i) => i.nodeId));
// 未回齐就等着 —— 别的分支到了会再来一次
if (!joinReady(pkg, target.id, converged, tolerated)) continue;
}
const assembled = assemble(edge, { ...scope, ports: { ...scope.ports, [fromNodeId]: payload } }, deps.sfeel.expression);
/*
* 网关不是责任单元,**按到达的东西路由**:它没有入参契约要满足,
* 上游的输出口载荷要原样穿过去,判据才读得到(如 G4 读 outcome)。
* 若只给边映射装配出来的那份,无映射的边就把判据依据整个丢掉,
* 异或网关会一条分支都选不中,整条流悄无声息地停住。
* 活动与审批点仍只收**装配后的**载荷 —— 它们有契约,不该被上游多余字段污染。
*/
const arriving = target.kind === 'gateway' ? { ...payload, ...assembled } : assembled;
try {
await enter(record, pkg, target, arriving);
} catch (error) {
/*
* 一条分支起不来,不该把整条终态上报连坐掀翻 —— 那会让**上游任务的终态也报不上去**,
* 流停在原地且一行日志都没有。这里把它记成工作流事件并落一个未激活的实例:
* 其余分支照走,这一支在治理台「需处置」里现形,等人处置。
*/
const detail = error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error);
await deps.events.publish({
workflowId: record.id,
kind: 'node-start-failed',
detail: { nodeId: target.id, from: fromNodeId, error: detail },
});
const instances = await deps.store.listInstances(record.id);
await deps.store.insertInstance(record.id, {
nodeId: target.id,
instance: nextInstanceNumber(instances, target.id),
running: false,
waiting: true,
activated: true,
terminal: 'blocked',
});
}
}
return edges.length > 0;
}
return {
async savePackage(pkg) {
await deps.store.savePackage(pkg);
return pkg;
},
async listPackages() {
return deps.store.listPackages();
},
async getPackage(id, version) {
return deps.store.getPackage(id, version);
},
/** 画图即校验:发布前跑闭合校验 */
async validate(pkg) {
return checkClosure({
pkg,
contracts: await deps.activities.faces(),
positions: await deps.org.positions(),
});
},
/** 不闭合不得发布 */
async publish(id, version) {
const pkg = await requirePackage(id, version);
const report = await this.validate(pkg);
if (!report.publishable) throw new NotPublishableError(report);
await deps.store.publishPackage(id, version);
return report;
},
/** 起单:经调用接口调起流程包,生成一条工作流 */
async start(input: StartWorkflowInput) {
const pkg =
input.packageVersion === undefined
? await latestPublished(input.packageId)
: await requirePackage(input.packageId, input.packageVersion);
if (pkg.state !== 'published') throw new Error(`流程包未发布,不得起单:${pkg.id}@${pkg.version}`);
// 先校验后建单:不合调用接口契约的输入**一条工作流都不留**。
// (校验若放在建单之后,失败就会留下一条永远推不动的在途单,污染在途口径。)
const check = deps.schemas.validate(pkg.callInterface.input, input.data);
if (!check.ok) throw new CallInterfaceViolationError(pkg.id, check.errors);
// 工作组按**来源人**装载(ADR-011):无来源人、或此人没建组 → 不装载,全走四策略
const binding =
input.source.by === undefined ? undefined : await deps.org.workGroupBinding(input.source.by);
const record: WorkflowRecord = {
id: deps.ids.next(),
packageId: pkg.id,
packageVersion: pkg.version,
subject: input.subject,
state: 'running',
source: input.source,
initiation: input.data,
ports: {},
vars: {},
startedAt: deps.clock.now().toISOString(),
...(binding === undefined ? {} : { workGroup: { ...binding } }),
};
await deps.store.insertWorkflow(record);
await deps.events.publish({ workflowId: record.id, kind: 'workflow-started', detail: { source: input.source } });
const start = startNodeOf(pkg);
if (start !== undefined) await advanceFrom(record, pkg, start.id, input.data);
return record;
},
async getWorkflow(id) {
return requireWorkflow(id);
},
async listWorkflows(limit = 50) {
return deps.store.listWorkflows(limit);
},
async instancesOf(workflowId) {
return deps.store.listInstances(workflowId);
},
/** 任务终态到达:按终态决定继续流转还是走失败走向 */
async onTaskTerminal(taskId, terminal: TerminalState, ports: Record<string, Record<string, unknown>>) {
const located = await deps.store.findInstanceByTask(taskId);
if (located === undefined) return undefined;
const record = await requireWorkflow(located.workflowId);
const pkg = await requirePackage(record.packageId, record.packageVersion);
const node = pkg.nodes.find((n) => n.id === located.nodeId);
await deps.store.updateInstance(record.id, located.nodeId, located.instance, {
running: false,
waiting: false,
terminal,
});
await deps.events.publish({ workflowId: record.id, kind: 'task-terminal', detail: { taskId, terminal } });
const merged = await deps.store.updateWorkflow(record.id, { ports: { ...record.ports, ...ports } });
if (terminal === 'released') {
// 落地收敛后才发射输出口 —— 下游只见落地完成的任务。
// 各口载荷合并成一份路由作用域:只取第一口,活动没有必交付口时就什么都拿不到。
const payload: Record<string, unknown> = Object.assign({}, ...Object.values(ports));
await advanceFrom(merged, pkg, located.nodeId, payload);
} else if (node?.kind === 'activity') {
// 非完成终态触发**声明的失败走向**;流程层不自动重试
await this.applyFailure(record.id, located.nodeId, located.instance, node, terminal);
}
return this.refreshState(record.id);
},
/** 失败走向四选一:终止流(默认)/ 改道 / 升审批 / 容忍 */
async applyFailure(workflowId, nodeId, instance, node, terminal) {
const record = await requireWorkflow(workflowId);
const pkg = await requirePackage(record.packageId, record.packageVersion);
const disposition = node.failure;
const digested = isDigested(disposition.kind);
await deps.store.updateInstance(workflowId, nodeId, instance, { failureDigested: digested });
await deps.events.publish({
workflowId,
kind: 'failure-disposition',
detail: { nodeId, terminal, disposition: disposition.kind },
});
if (disposition.kind === 'reroute') {
const edge = pkg.edges.find((e) => e.id === disposition.edgeId);
const target = edge === undefined ? undefined : pkg.nodes.find((n) => n.id === edge.to);
if (edge !== undefined && target !== undefined) {
// 失败载荷 = 终态、原因码与说明
const payload = assemble(edge, scopeOf(record), deps.sfeel.expression);
await enter(record, pkg, target, { ...payload, __terminal: terminal });
}
}
if (disposition.kind === 'escalate') {
const target = pkg.nodes.find((n) => n.id === disposition.approvalNodeId);
if (target !== undefined) await enter(record, pkg, target, { __terminal: terminal, __from: nodeId });
}
if (disposition.kind === 'tolerate') {
/*
* 容忍 = 这条支线的失败被吸收,**流继续往下走**。
* 只把实例标成「已消化」而不往下推,汇合就永远等不到它:
* `joinReady` 认 tolerated,可没人再去问一次它够不够齐。
* 载荷为空 —— 容忍分支本就没有产出,下游的必填映射不得依赖它(闭合校验已拦)。
*/
await advanceFrom(record, pkg, nodeId, {});
}
return this.refreshState(workflowId);
},
/** 审批裁决:通过继续流转;驳回按**声明的走向**回指定节点重开新实例 */
async onApprovalVerdict(workflowId, nodeId, verdict, payload) {
const record = await requireWorkflow(workflowId);
const pkg = await requirePackage(record.packageId, record.packageVersion);
const node = pkg.nodes.find((n) => n.id === nodeId);
if (node?.kind !== 'approval') throw new Error(`节点不是审批点:${nodeId}`);
const instances = await deps.store.listInstances(workflowId);
const current = instances.filter((i) => i.nodeId === nodeId).at(-1);
if (current !== undefined) {
await deps.store.updateInstance(workflowId, nodeId, current.instance, {
waiting: false,
terminal: 'released',
});
}
await deps.events.publish({ workflowId, kind: 'approval-verdict', detail: { nodeId, verdict } });
/*
* **裁决进载荷**:审批点后面跟网关时,网关判的就是这个字段
* (如 G3「审批结果」的 `verdict = "pass"` / `verdict = "reject"`)。
*
* 从前只有 pass 走 `advanceFrom`,而且 payload 里不含 `verdict` —— 于是审批点后面
* 就算画了网关也判不了(异或分叉的每条出边都得带条件、没有无条件兜底边,
* 判据一缺就全不成立,流无声停在网关上)。要让它判得了,只能在边上挂一枚
* 常量 `verdict: "pass"` 骗过条件 —— 那网关就成了摆设:条件恒真、驳回那条边永不可达。
* 图上画着两个去向、其中一个结构上走不到,是在说谎。
*/
const carried = { ...payload, verdict };
if (verdict === 'pass') {
await advanceFrom(record, pkg, nodeId, carried);
} else {
/*
* 驳回:**先看图**。图上显式画了驳回出边(审批点后面跟网关)就走边 —— 编排即定契约,
* 图是真相。没画的包才退回 `reject` 声明:它是 schema 必填的通用机制,
* 不是所有流程包都会把驳回画成边。
*
* `quiet` 传真:这一步「试边不成」是正常分支,不是死路,不该报 route-dead-end。
*/
const routedByEdge = await advanceFrom(record, pkg, nodeId, carried, true);
if (!routedByEdge) {
const route = rejectRouteOf(node, scopeOf(record), deps.sfeel.expression);
if (route.kind === 'terminate') {
await deps.store.updateWorkflow(workflowId, { state: 'terminated', finishedAt: deps.clock.now().toISOString() });
} else {
// 回指定节点**重开新实例**(同节点、新任务 ID、留痕关联),不复活旧任务
const target = pkg.nodes.find((n) => n.id === route.nodeId);
if (target !== undefined) await enter(record, pkg, target, { ...route.payload, ...payload });
}
}
}
return this.refreshState(workflowId);
},
/** 工作流状态是聚合投影 —— 每次变动后重算 */
async refreshState(workflowId): Promise<WorkflowState> {
const record = await requireWorkflow(workflowId);
if (record.state === 'terminated') return 'terminated';
const instances = await deps.store.listInstances(workflowId);
// 「完成」凭到过终点,不凭没有在跑的了 —— 所以要把包的终点节点交给聚合
const pkg = await deps.store.getPackage(record.packageId, record.packageVersion);
const endNodeIds = (pkg?.nodes ?? []).filter((n) => n.kind === 'end').map((n) => n.id);
const state = aggregateWorkflowState(instances as NodeInstance[], false, endNodeIds);
if (state !== record.state) {
await deps.store.updateWorkflow(workflowId, {
state,
...(state === 'completed' ? { finishedAt: deps.clock.now().toISOString() } : {}),
});
}
return state;
},
async terminate(workflowId, reason) {
await deps.store.updateWorkflow(workflowId, {
state: 'terminated',
finishedAt: deps.clock.now().toISOString(),
});
// 工作流终止级联:在途任务终止、待答卡与征答消息作废、审批点撤卡
await deps.events.publish({ workflowId, kind: 'workflow-terminated', detail: { reason } });
return 'terminated';
},
};
}